← Back to all articles
Reddit r/MachineLearningSeptember 25, 2026

What's up with AAAI reviewers and organizers? [D]

Excerpt

My paper advanced to the second round...but... Out of the papers I reviewed. One did not follow the AAAI template and was unblinded. My review was two lines. The other "human reviewer" gave a list of pros and cons that were similar to the AI review. One was incomplete (missing paragraphs, figures, code, no details). My review was also two lines. The other "human reviewer" also gave a list of pros and cons, that were similar to the AI review. One was LLM math which I believe was actually correct,